Boiler vs. furnace: which is healthier?

At HVAC.com, our writers create options that put you accountable for your HVAC system. Our product critiques and suggestions are researched and backed by actual patrons and business consultants, not dictated by our companions.

Relating to whole-home heating, boiler vs. furnace is considered one of your choices. Each distribute heat to maintain your private home snug. 

Boilers and furnaces use totally different strategies to warmth your private home. On this piece, you’ll learn the way they work and the professionals and cons of every. 

What’s the distinction between boiler and furnace?

Boilers are a kind of radiant heater. They use both fuel, oil, or coal to heat water in a vessel. The water or steam (relying in your mannequin) is then distributed to radiators all through the house for heating. 

There are a number of radiator types:

• Baseboard radiators
• Massive steam radiators
• Radiant flooring methods

Alternatively, furnaces heat air and flow into it via ductwork in a house. Furnaces burn gasoline to create warmth. They use an air handler to push heat air into the house. 

Heat air disperses via the house’s air ducts. It blows out via vents in every room, warming the area.  

Furnaces can use various kinds of gasoline, like boilers, together with electrical energy, fuel, and oil.

Boiler vs. furnace value

In keeping with the 2023 Nationwide Plumbing and HVAC Estimator, the price of residential boilers ranges $4,378-17,240. HomeAdvisor says the common new boiler prices $5,810.  

The Nationwide Plumbing and HVAC Estimator states new residential furnaces vary $1,010-5,764. HomeAdvisor says the common new furnace prices $4,690. 

The common lifespan of a boiler is 20 years. The common lifespan of a furnace is 15-30 years. How lengthy every lasts relies on how you utilize the equipment and the way properly it’s maintained.

Along with budgeting for the equipment itself, you’ll must pay for set up. It’s simpler for HVAC technicians to put in a furnace than a boiler.

A furnace takes a number of hours, however boiler set up can take a number of days. Due to this fact, boiler set up is considerably costlier.

Boilers require much less upkeep. A furnace ought to have an annual tuneup to maintain it operating successfully. This includes a small expense. 

Boiler vs. furnace gasoline sort

Most often, electrical home equipment are the least costly. Oil home equipment value probably the most upfront, with fuel home equipment within the center.

The price of operating a heating equipment relies on the gasoline it burns, as properly. Typically, fuel is the least costly heating gasoline, adopted by electrical energy and oil.

In 2022-2023, all heating gasoline costs are up. Gasoline costs, particularly, are spiking, up greater than 34 % this winter. 

Boiler vs. furnace effectivity

Boilers are normally extra fuel-efficient than furnaces. In flip, your month-to-month energy invoice will most likely be much less with a boiler.

Boilers and furnaces are each rated for Annual Gasoline Utilization Effectivity (AFUE). AFUE measures the gasoline effectivity of your heating equipment.

A heating equipment with an AFUE of 90% wastes 10% of its gasoline and makes use of 90% to warmth your private home.

The upper the AFUE ranking, the extra environment friendly your boiler or furnace. When purchasing for a boiler or furnace, you may instantly examine their effectivity by in search of the AFUE ranking.

In keeping with Power.gov, a high-efficiency heating system has an AFUE of 90-98.5 %. 

Which is healthier? Boiler vs. furnace

In the USA, boilers aren’t presently fashionable for dwelling heating. Most properties with boilers are older and exist within the northeastern area.

Adapting your private home for a boiler might be pricey and inefficient until you could have an current radiant heating system.

Nonetheless, boilers might be useful in sure conditions.

Boiler professionals and cons

Furnace professionals and cons

Most properties at this time are constructed with ductwork; so a furnace is a logical selection for heating them. However when you’re ranging from scratch, take into account these potential advantages and disadvantages.

The underside line: furnace vs. boiler

Although boilers have some compelling advantages, we don’t suggest putting in one until your private home already has a radiant heating system. We discover radiant heating installations costly and cumbersome, even when you’re constructing a brand new dwelling.

Heating through ductwork with a furnace is preferable in most situations. We suggest an electrical furnace if your private home has applicable hookups. Because the utility grid turns into extra sustainable and we transfer in direction of decarbonization, electrical home equipment would be the best possibility.