The 2026 midterm elections are over, but the results could have significant implications for refrigerant policy. With Democrats making substantial gains at the federal, state, and local levels, the political landscape has changed, raising concerns that more states could pursue stricter refrigerant regulations before the HVACR industry has the equipment, safety standards, and training needed for another transition.
For Sean Robertson, vice president of government relations at Air Conditioning Contractors of America (ACCA), the election results reinforce the need to focus on what comes next rather than revisiting the existing refrigerant phasedown.
“While some contractors may wish for a return to R-410A or R-22, this election removes all doubt that the AIM Act and its HFC phasedown schedule are here to stay,” he said. “ACCA believes we must focus on preventing the next crisis rather than relitigating the last one.”
That next crisis, said Robertson, could be a patchwork of state refrigerant regulations that push the industry to prematurely transition to highly flammable A3 refrigerants, such as R-290 (propane).
The election results could make that scenario more likely. Starting in 2027, Democrats will hold a majority of governorships nationwide. The party also gained six state government trifectas, bringing its total to 22, with Democrats holding the governor’s office and majorities in both legislative chambers. Robertson believes those shifts in political control could make it easier for states to establish their own GWP limits, refrigerant sales restrictions, and equipment installation deadlines.
“That’s exactly the outcome the AIM Act was supposed to prevent,” said Robertson.
That is why ACCA favors federal preemption, which would prevent states from imposing requirements that go beyond the national phasedown, but that will be difficult to achieve under the new Congress, said Robertson.
Looking for quick answers on air conditioning, heating and refrigeration topics?
Try Ask ACHR NEWS, our new smart AI search tool.
Ask ACHR NEWS
“The case for preemption isn’t partisan. It’s about affordability, safety, and a predictable transition. ACCA will keep making that case to members of both parties so it’s ready when the right legislative vehicle comes along.”
The Plumbing-Heating–Cooling Contractors–National Association (PHCC) also favors preemption and shares concerns about states getting ahead of the A2L transition. Mark Valentini, vice president of legislative affairs at PHCC, said the industry has invested considerable time and resources in transitioning to products that comply with the AIM Act, and additional state requirements could undermine that work.
Chuck White, vice president of regulatory affairs at PHCC, added that certain states moving to refrigerants such as A3s “would force redesign of products, new inventory distribution, code change adoptions, and new/updated training programs, none of which leads to more affordable products.”
Alex Ayers, vice president of government affairs at Heating, Air-conditioning & Refrigeration Distributors International (HARDI), also questioned the need for more restrictions, noting that “there is an unfortunate misconception that an additional forced transition to ultra-low-GWP refrigerants will increase the climate benefits of HFC policy. EPA has said that lower-GWP limits do not provide meaningful climate benefits.”
Ayers does not expect new state restrictions to take effect within the next few years, but said HARDI will closely monitor upcoming legislative sessions, particularly in U.S. Climate Alliance states and those that recently elected Democratic leadership. The association’s priority is to oppose regulations that increase consumer costs without providing additional climate benefits.
“We’ll be communicating to those states that we are fully opposed to any additional forced refrigerant transitions,” he said.
At the federal level, however, Ayers expects little change to the AIM Act. Nearly six years after the law’s passage, no legislation has been introduced to amend it, and he sees little reason to believe the incoming Congress will take action. While EPA has the authority to modify regulations implementing the law, Ayers believes changes are unlikely in the near term, particularly given recent leadership changes at the agency and the prospect of increased congressional oversight.
Rather than pursuing additional refrigerant restrictions, HARDI wants regulators to focus on enforcing existing requirements. For example, Ayers said the association is seeing increasing amounts of noncompliant R-410A equipment entering the market, along with widespread online sales of illegal and counterfeit refrigerants.
“We are looking for ways to help EPA and state agencies enforce the laws that are already in place to reduce the use of HFCs,” he said.
Washington Moves Ahead
The concerns over the next refrigerant transition are already playing out in Washington state. On October 30, 2026, the State Building Code Council (SBCC) voted unanimously to adopt amendments to the 2024 Washington State Mechanical Code that would allow the use of A3 refrigerants in certain types of HVAC equipment starting in May 2027.
Safety was the main concern for opponents, including the Washington State Association of Fire Marshals and other fire safety officials, who warned about the difficulty of detecting leaks involving refrigerants without added odorants. Supporters argued that the amendment would allow outdoor monobloc equipment, similar to systems used in Europe, which keeps the refrigerant outside and transfers heat into the building through a water loop.
Although the amendments do not mandate A3 refrigerants, ACCA, HARDI, AHRI, and PHCC also opposed the changes, arguing that the necessary safety standards and installation requirements were not yet in place.
“Almost everybody in our industry agrees that New York and Washington are moving way too fast with A3 transitions before standards, consensus codes, training, certification, logistics, and commercially available equipment are in place,” said Robertson.
Stephen Yurek, president and CEO of AHRI, raised similar concerns in a November 11 opinion piece published in The Spokesman-Review, a Spokane, Washington, newspaper. He warned that research supporting highly flammable refrigerants in central HVAC systems remains in its early stages. He also raised concerns about the lack of established emergency response procedures for firefighters responding to incidents involving propane in residential HVAC equipment.
“We’ve been through refrigerant transitions before,” wrote Yurek. “We know that they work best when they’re done carefully, deliberately, and with safety at the center.”
Beyond the immediate safety concerns, HARDI questioned whether standards developed for other markets can be applied to American HVAC systems. Ayers noted that European equipment designs and heating and cooling requirements often differ from those in the United States.
“We will not support a forced transition to refrigerants with no documented safety standards for the systems we use in North America,” he said.
In addition, Washington already has a Refrigerant Transition Task Force that is examining product availability, workforce training, safety, and implementation timelines. According to Ayers, its work is demonstrating why ultra-low-GWP refrigerants are not practical for every application.
“Many sectors already use ultra-low-GWP refrigerants in safe, effective designs, but what works in one sector does not mean it works in all sectors and applications,” he said.
New York’s Aggressive Deadlines
Washington isn’t the only state moving forward with ultra-low-GWP refrigerants. New York has already established GWP limits that could effectively require the use of ultra-low-GWP refrigerants for certain types of HVACR equipment.
Under its amended 6 NYCRR Part 494 regulations, “New York State will prohibit even the new A2L refrigerants starting in 2027 for heat pump water heaters, 2030 for VRF and chillers, and 2034 for almost everything else,” said Robertson.
“It would be very reckless for any state to follow New York State, where we are in active litigation to remove the impossible restrictions the state put in place,” said Ayers. HARDI is among the industry groups challenging New York’s regulations, which the association argues impose unrealistic requirements on equipment manufacturers, distributors, and contractors.
Ayers noted that the current HFC transition took more than a decade of industry preparation, but no comparable effort has been made for an industry-wide shift to ultra-low-GWP refrigerants. He believes some New York regulators underestimate the challenges involved, mistaking the HVACR industry’s concerns for resistance to change.
More States Could Follow
The question now is whether other states could follow Washington and New York’s lead, adopting policies that accelerate the transition to highly flammable A3 refrigerants. Robertson identified Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, and Wisconsin as states with new Democratic trifectas that ACCA is watching closely.
“We’re also keeping a close eye on states with draft rules or active advocacy campaigns, including Oregon, Hawaii, Colorado, New Mexico, Illinois, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland, Massachusetts, and Maine, along with the states that already have rules on the books: California, Washington, and New York,” said Robertson.
He added that any new policies would likely borrow from what’s already been adopted. “That could mean premature adoption of highly flammable A3 refrigerants like propane in residential codes as proposed in Washington; a ban on the sale of virgin HFC refrigerants, like New York and California have adopted; installation deadlines that undo the relief EPA provided this year on R-410A equipment; or, most concerning, GWP limits low enough to rule out A2L refrigerants and force an unsafe transition to A3 refrigerants.”
PHCC is also keeping an eye on California and U.S. Climate Alliance states that could follow Washington and New York’s lead. However, Valentini cautioned that changes in political control don’t necessarily mean new refrigerant regulations are coming. Even if newly elected Democratic leaders pursue A3 refrigerant policies, he questioned whether voters would support another transition, noting that “these policies are a tough sell on a public that sees a more direct tie to gas and grocery prices.”
HARDI also opposes additional state-mandated refrigerant transitions, arguing that market demand will drive the adoption of ultra-low-GWP alternatives where practical.
“We’ve seen how well the market has been able to transition in several sectors to ultra-low-GWP where practicable, and as the phasedown continues, the market will help drive the sectors that can transition to those refrigerants on its own,” said Ayers.
In the meantime, ACCA is urging contractors to get involved before new regulations are adopted. Robertson said contractors should contact state legislators, participate in public hearings, and comment on proposed code changes as soon as possible, because the next two months matter.
“Most legislatures convene in January, and new majorities set their priorities before then,” said Robertson. “This is the best time for a contractor to introduce themselves to a new legislator and explain how refrigerant rules play out on a real job, before bills are drafted.”
Whether you require installation, repair, or maintenance, our technicians will assist you with top-quality service at any time of the day or night. Take comfort in knowing your indoor air quality is the best it can be with MOE heating & cooling services Ontario's solution for heating, air conditioning, and ventilation that’s cooler than the rest.
Contact us to schedule a visit. Our qualified team of technicians, are always ready to help you and guide you for heating and cooling issues. Weather you want to replace an old furnace or install a brand new air conditioner, we are here to help you. Our main office is at Kitchener but we can service most of Ontario's cities
Source link


