Startup Spillage: When the Building Pulls the Flue Backward

Startup Spillage: When the Building Pulls the Flue Backward


Key Takeaways
  1. A cold flue is the weakest moment: Natural draft depends on hot flue gas rising. In the first minutes after light-off the vent is cold, the draft is weak, and a building under negative pressure can pull combustion products into the room.
  2. Test under worst case, not as found: The published procedures close the doors and windows, run the exhaust fans and the dryer, fire the appliance, and then check for spillage at the draft hood with smoke.
  3. Know the limits, and which procedure they come from: Vermont’s worst-case procedure fails an appliance that spills for more than 60 seconds and allows only 2 to 5 pascals of depressurization for most natural draft appliances. BPI-1200 times its spillage checks differently.
  4. Fix the building, not the symptom: Makeup air, restored combustion air openings, or a sealed-combustion replacement cure spillage. “It drafts fine once it warms up” means occupants breathe flue gas on every start.

The boiler room smells sharp at startup. A few minutes in, the smell fades and the draft gauge reads normal, so the call gets closed. That pattern deserves a second look. A natural draft appliance that spills on every start is putting combustion products into the building several times a day, and the cause is usually something in the building, not the appliance.

Why Natural Draft Loses the Tug of War

A natural draft (Category I, atmospheric) appliance relies on buoyancy. Hot flue gas is lighter than the air around it, so it rises up the vent and pulls fresh air through the draft hood behind it. The hotter and taller the vent, the stronger the pull.

At light-off the vent is cold, so the pull is weakest exactly when the burner starts producing flue gas. That pull is small to begin with. Vermont’s worst-case procedure only asks for a draft at least as strong as -2.5 pascals below 10°F outdoors, and -0.5 pascals above 90°F.¹ A pascal is a tiny pressure: there are about 249 in one inch of water column.

Now put that appliance in a room the building is pulling negative. If the room is more negative than the vent can pull, the flow reverses. Flue gas spills out of the draft hood into the room until the vent heats up enough to win, or it never wins at all. That is why the screening limits below are much looser for induced draft and sealed-combustion appliances.

What Pulls a Building Negative

Anything that moves air out of the building without a matched path back in:

  • Exhaust fans. Bath fans, range hoods, kitchen hood systems, shop exhaust, paint booths. In a house with a natural draft appliance inside the air barrier, the IRC requires makeup air for an exhaust system capable of more than 400 CFM.² Plenty of homes run big hoods without it.
  • Clothes dryers. A dryer exhausts room air to the outdoors for as long as it runs.
  • Air handler leakage. Return leaks inside the mechanical room, or a return grille in the furnace closet, pull that room negative when the blower runs.
  • Other combustion appliances and fireplaces. A fireplace or a second appliance with a hot chimney pulls air that the cold vent next to it needed.
  • Construction and renovation. Tightened windows, sealed attics, new exhaust, and commercial buildings where half the floor is being converted while the other half keeps running. A natural draft boiler that drafted fine for years can start spilling because someone else changed the building. On a commercial call, ask the superintendent or project manager what changed, because the trades on site often are not talking to each other.

Commercial spaces are the classic case. Natural draft unit heaters and boilers in shops, warehouses and restaurants share the space with exhaust fans that may have no interlocked makeup air. In those buildings the spillage often shows up only on the coldest days, when doors stay closed and every fan runs.

Testing Spillage the Way the Procedures Do

The International Fuel Gas Code’s informative Appendix D, on inspecting existing appliances, lays out the core test.³ Close the building’s exterior doors and windows and the doors between the appliance space and other rooms. Close fireplace dampers and doors. Turn on the clothes dryer and the exhaust fans, such as range hoods and bath fans, at full speed. Do not run a summer exhaust fan. Fire the appliance being inspected and, after 5 minutes of main burner operation, check for spillage at the draft hood with smoke. Then fire the other gas appliances in the room and test again. Repeat with the room door open and closed, and with any air handlers running.

Weatherization procedures go further. They measure the combustion appliance zone (CAZ) pressure against outdoors, find the worst-case combination of fans, doors and air handler, and compare it to a limit by appliance type. Efficiency Vermont’s code appendix, based on BPI’s worst-case procedure, lists these screening limits (abridged; the table has more venting rows):¹

  • Atmospheric water heater, alone: -2 Pa
  • Category I furnace or boiler common-vented with a Category I water heater: -3 Pa
  • Category I or II furnace or boiler, alone: -5 Pa
  • Induced draft furnace or boiler, or fan-assisted water heater, alone: -15 Pa
  • Category IV direct-vent and sealed combustion: -50 Pa

The same appendix fails an appliance that keeps spilling for more than 60 seconds, measures draft 1 to 2 feet downstream of the draft diverter, and checks flue CO at 10 minutes.¹ ANSI/BPI-1200 times it differently: spillage at 5 minutes on a cold vent, but at 2 minutes on domestic water heaters and warm vents, with flue CO taken at 5 minutes either way.⁴ Use one procedure from start to finish, the one your jurisdiction or program requires, and don’t mix timings and limits from different documents. A scheduled reading time is never permission to keep a spilling appliance running.

Wear Your Monitor Into the Boiler Room

Spillage testing puts the tech in the exact air the test is designed to catch. Turn on a personal CO monitor before walking into the space, not after the appliance fires. The Vermont procedure monitors ambient CO continuously and stops the test if indoor CO goes above 35 ppm: shut off the appliance, ventilate, evacuate and fix the CO problem before going on.¹ BPI-1200 uses its own tiers, starting at 9 ppm and calling for evacuation at 70 ppm.⁴ Headaches, nausea, or a sharp smell at startup are reasons to check ambient CO before doing anything else.

Startup spillage is easy to miss with a monitor in the truck. By the time the tech walks back in, the vent is hot and drafting. The carbon monoxide field guide covers ambient testing from the door to the appliance.

Fixing It Without Guessing

Match the fix to the cause the test found:

  • Exhaust with no makeup air: add makeup air sized to the exhaust that opens or runs whenever the fan does. On commercial kitchens and shops this is the usual answer.
  • Blocked or missing combustion air openings: restore them to the size the code and the appliance manual require. Look for openings closed off during a renovation or blocked by storage.
  • Return leaks in the mechanical room: seal them and remove return grilles from closets that hold natural draft appliances.
  • Vent problems: an oversized, undersized, or orphaned water heater vent left alone in a big chimney after the furnace was replaced can fail the test with nothing wrong in the building. Fix the vent before chasing fans.
  • A building that will stay negative: replace the natural draft appliance with a sealed-combustion, direct-vent one. Vermont’s screening limit for those is -50 pascals, ten times the -5 for an atmospheric furnace alone.¹

Write down what you found: the fans and doors in the test, the CAZ pressure if you measured it, how long it spilled, ambient and flue CO. The red tag documentation guide covers what to record when the answer is a shutdown. For what the flue readings mean once the appliance is drafting, see the combustion analysis guide.

An appliance that spills on startup is a building problem the appliance is reporting. Test it the way it actually runs, with the fans on and the doors shut, and fix what the test points to.


Additional Sources
  1. “Appendix RA: Procedure for Worst-Case Testing of Combustion Appliances”, Efficiency Vermont, 2020 Vermont Residential Building Energy Standards, 2020.
  2. “International Residential Code, Section M1503.6 Makeup Air Required”, International Code Council, Code, 2021.
  3. “International Fuel Gas Code, Appendix D: Recommended Procedure for Safety Inspection of an Existing Appliance Installation”, International Code Council, Code Appendix, 2021.
  4. “ANSI/BPI-1200-S-2017 Standard Practice for Basic Analysis of Buildings”, Building Performance Institute, Standard, 2017.



Whether you require installation, repair, or maintenance, our technicians will assist you with top-quality service at any time of the day or night. Take comfort in knowing your indoor air quality is the best it can be with MOE heating & cooling services Ontario's solution for heating, air conditioning, and ventilation that’s cooler than the rest.
Contact us to schedule a visit. Our qualified team of technicians, are always ready to help you and guide you for heating and cooling issues. Weather you want to replace an old furnace or install a brand new air conditioner, we are here to help you. Our main office is at Kitchener but we can service most of Ontario's cities


Source link